Conflicting Tube Info!!!
Conflicting Tube Info!!! |
Music Man Amps Discussion Forum » Tubes & Substitutions » Conflicting Tube Info!!!
Author | Message | ||
Spino |
I'm trying to get some spare tubes for my 112 RD 100,(this is all the info I've got on the amp without removing screws) |
||
michael kaus |
You need to look inside your amp and see if it has GD2,GD2A, or GD1 written in it anywhere. THe GD2 amps used 6ca7's, the GD1 amps used 6ca7's, the GD2A amps used 6L6's. Confusing, huh! No matter what, those amps DO have 700v or so on the plates. Tell that guy to look at the freking schematic before he shoots his mouth off. That's a good way to blow things up. I don't know for sure which amp you have but 6L6's were used in somne of those amps. You'll have to open it up and look for any other numbers but I would guss that the 6L6's would be right for that last series of amps and 83 was near the end. Mike. |
||
Spino |
Hi Mike, |
||
Anonymous |
Ill say 6L6.... too new for the older 6au7 tubes... |
||
Anonymous |
6ca7....sorry |
||
Spino |
Hey Michael |
||
Spino |
Oh!... BTW the Tube chart says 6L6's....So there shouldnt be any question...Right!! |
||
Anonymous |
Nope |
||
Mark Rogers (gogogophers) Username: gogogophers Registered: 06-2006 |
OK, call me what you want, but my head is spinning from too much information. I have tried surfing the site heavily so as to not ask stupid questions. No luck. Per this thread, I also have a 112 RD 100. I do not know what year it is. I also took everything apart and could not find the "gd" marks as mentioned. When I bought it (late 80's) it had 6Ca7's and I had an extra pair of GE 6Ca7's that I don't even remember where I they came from. I recently (before I found this site) replaced them with Groove Tube EL34's, because I thought they were equivalent. The 34's work. The amp sounds good. Could it sound better ? At this point I don't know. A little feedback please. The end of this thread seems to suggest that, if it's a 112 RD 100, you should be using 6L6's. Please bring this down to the small brained folk like myself. If it's supposed to be using 6L6's, should the amp even function with EL34s ? If it is supposed to have 6Ca7's, what are the real world implications of replacing them with EL34's. Is the amp being harmed ? Is the tube life less, but the amp is fine ? Is there a sound quality issue ? Should I have it re-biased (whatever that means) ? Thanks for putting up with a amp rookie. These amps rule, I have been gigging with this thing since '86. Great site. |
||
Steve Kennedy (admin) Username: admin Registered: 03-2002 |
The short version: The earliest RD65 and 100 amps were probably shipped with EL34s or perhaps the very earliest with 6CA7s. The U.S. made 6CA7 is a mechanically stronger tube and better suited to the MM amps than the EL34 mainly because of the larger physical spacing between the tube elements in the 6CA7 (which is more compatible with the high plate-voltage found in the MM amps). The 6CA7 was the tube these amps were originally designed for. |
Member for
10 years 9 monthsMember for
10 years 9 monthsThoughts are that it's a nice
Thoughts are that it's a nice amp but you PROBABLY need to determine WHICH amp you have. See post two at the top but you're looking for a number on one of the boards that says GD1, GD2 or GD2a. That will determine which tubes and schematic to use, then you can go from there. Mike.
112 RD 100 - 6l6GC or EL34L
I bought my black badge 112 RD 100 about 10 yrs ago on eBay, about for about $230. It had Groove Tube EL34s in it. It would occasionally get an uncontrollable scratchy sound so I took it to a tech. According to the invoice (not my memory!), he replaced existing tubes with JJ EL34L, adjusted the bias, cleaned some pots and jacks and sent me on my way. That never really resolved the problem. Sometimes it worked, sometimes not. Meaning that sometimes I would take out the tubes, re-seat them, and the scratchy sound would stop. Fast forward to last year...scratchiness goes extreme, smoke fills the room and it's dead.
I have an electrical engineer friend working with me to fix the amp(so far, only determined that it has a blown resistor)
While it's apart I'd like to replace anything that should proactively be replaced, which includes using 6L6 GCs (like I'm supposed to?) and re-biasing. I'll do it if it will make a difference.
With the EL34l tubes I always ran on low power and it seemed to work, but, I want stability. The JJ web site says the EL34L's are rated for higher power so maybe it's a non-issue.
I won't ever really be driving this thing hard enough for power tube break up, so I'm not looking at this from a tone perspective. For what I do, the EL34's seem to be fine, and the 6L6s would probably be fine too. I just want the amp to be reliable, sound good and be a clean platform for pedals. I have 6 watter for tube breakup. A stadium is the only venue for taking this RD100 to 10 and tube distortion.
Thoughts?